on dumb ideas - Bega Valley Shire Residents & Ratepayers Association

Go to content

Main menu:

on dumb ideas …

In yet another questionable report, council’s general manager revealed at last week’s ordinary meeting that council had received an “unsolicited” proposal from an airline seeking approval to commence a trial air passenger service between Sydney & Merimbula, commencing in mid-December.

Council resolved to consider the proposal in “closed session” & in doing so “flagged” its willingness to negotiate a potentially more attractive set of commercial arrangements with the applicant to those currently applying to the shire’s long-standing service provider, Rex.

The association does not share council’s obvious enthusiasm for the “unsolicited” proposal from Qantas & thinks that the uncertainty surrounding the short to medium term future of airlines due to the Covid2019 pandemic is more than enough reason to have declined the proposal.

Meanwhile, while official statistics indicate that annual Merimbula passenger movements (43,611) for 2019-20120 were the lowest in 15 years, according to the report to council, they have actually declined by 95% over the past nine months, meaning that they have shrunk to a point where they are negligible.

As for those constantly whinging about airfares being too high, Rex report that their average ticket prices have only risen by an average of 1.1% in the past 17 years.  

Notwithstanding its inept management of the airport expansion project & the new realities of a post-Covid world, council has remained driven by a fixation on a failing “build it & they’ll come” strategy. Coupled with its inability to effectively manage its long-term relationship with Rex, council’s latest move involving Qantas appears to be little more than another high stakes gamble.

Of course Rex reacted predictably to the news, announcing that it would withdraw from servicing the route, leaving council, as well as residents & ratepayers, to ponder what the future might bring should Qantas decide not to continue its service beyond the trial period & at once making the claim by council’s Mayor, Russell Fitzpatrick, that the move by Qantas would "offer greater choice & value for customers, helping bring more visitors to the region" totally ridiculous.

And while Qantas fan, Neil Hansford, of Strategic Aviation Services, was keen to criticise Rex on ABC Radio earlier this week, repeatedly accusing the airline of “bullying” council, he seems to have forgotten that back in 2017 he endorsed Rex's criticisms of council & forecast that the entry of a 2nd airline to the Merimbula-Sydney route would likely result in Rex abandoning it altogether.

Notwithstanding Hansford’s current criticism of Rex, he made it clear that the introduction of new services will not lead to an increase in tourist passenger numbers.

As the association has previously highlighted, the overwhelming majority of passenger movements associated with Merimbula Airport are not tourism-related & suggestions by council that the involvement of Qantas in the Sydney-Merimbula route will result in an increase in tourism numbers are completely unjustified.

And finally, while the general manager advised council that “The proposal as outlined by the company is consistent with the Merimbula Airport Masterplan …”, she didn’t bother to remind council that more than four years ago it had resolved “to update the Merimbula Regional Airport Masterplan with the latest research and analysis, considering the altered forecasts surrounding this project and report back to Council for adoption.

The sad reality is that in our future Covid2019 world, council’s ambition of turning the south coast into a “fly-in, fly-out” tourist Mecca, attracting hundreds of thousands of additional tourist visitors to the area, is now even less likely to be realised, while Merimbula Airport will remain just another glaring example of council’s wilful irresponsibility & mismanagement.


John Richardson
Secretary/Treasurer
Bega Valley Shire Residents & Ratepayers Association

Tel: 0264945669
Email: secretary@begavalleyshireratepayers.asn.au
Website: http://www.begavalleyshireratepayers.asn.au
 
Home Page | Our Purpose | Constitution | Office Bearers | Membership Application | Donations | Local Government in NSW | Bega Valley Shire | Brickbats & Bouquets | "Great Work" | Fit for the Future | Media Releases | Submissions | Reports - 2014 | Reports - 2013 | Reports - 2012 | Reports - 2011 | Buchanan | Reports - 2015 | Reports - 2016 | Reports - 2017 | Reports - 2018 | Reports - 2019 | Reports - 2020 | Reports - 2021 | Opinions - 2016 (Vol 1) | Opinions - 2016 (Vol 2) | Opinions - 2017 (Vol 1) | Opinions - 2017 (Vol 2) | Opinions - 2017 (Vol 3) | Opinions - 2018 (Vol 1) | Opinions - 2018 (Vol 2) | Opinions - 2018 (Vol 3) | Opinions - 2019 (Vol 1) | Opinions - 2019 (Vol 2) | Opinions - 2019 (Vol 3) | Opinions - 2020 (Vol 1) | Opinions - 2020 (Vol 2) | Opinions - 2021 (Vol 1) | jewel in the crown | on misinfomation | freedom of speech | on obfuscation | on real estate | when pigs might fly | on puzzles | on negligence | like a thief in the night | on alleged fraud | the common touch | just another sad joke | flogged with a feather | in plain sight | simple evidence | alarum, alarum | on community consultation | a familiar refrain | on tax | on arrogant conceit | a real shambles | on Heritage | a law unto itself | once upon a time | on phony regulation | chaos reigns | follow the money | on productivity | on public trust | a familiar refrain | on accountability | sleight of hand | on abusing trust | she said | on muddy waters | an abuse of power | more fake news | on empty promises | on dumb ideas | betrayed | on nonsense | drive-in, drive-out democracy | on diversity | value for money | avoiding the tears | down the rabbit hole | on openness & transparency | fractured fairy tales | too little, too late | a matter of capability | road to recovery | just another moment in time | 2021 Council Election | taking care of business | double trouble | on building trust | rubbish | on cover-ups | howling at the Moon | on White Elephants | on incompetence | on transparency | on open minds | from Fantasy Land | just more dysfunction | all the world's a stage | on Democracy | Well Done | a recipe for disaster | on trust | on the nose | a moment in time | a one track mind | ready, fire, aim | a moment in time | the leadership thing | final call | dirty tricks | time's up | Poor Fellow Our Country | what a joke | on public trust | from bad to worse | on negligence | same old, same old | on a flat earth | fair & balanced | just kickin' the can | "the Voice" | whither accountability | too late she cried | the fix | on settlement | what's in a name | quelle horreur | business as usual | wrong-footed | and the band played-on | just for a laugh | just another rip-off | killing democracy | nitpicking again | nitpicking indeed | pigs will fly | beneath contempt | on the nose | games they pplay | lights out | on community service | water works | on chutzpah | breaking news | on self-interest | taking care of business | keeping-up appearances | on government | from disaster to recovery | in search of a miracle | from the sublime to the ridiculous | on disasters | on sticks & stones | a law unto itself | on crying poor | on the nose | same old, same old | on grand plans | the gang that can't shoot straight | generous to a fault | a financial shambles | in treacherous waters | on deception | just another scam | on name calling | on phony numbers | end of the road | the Palace of Dreams | on doing nothing | on the basics | on incompetence | on bad dreams | mr spin | making every voice matter | shakedown | organised crime | 2019 Annual General Meeting | paying the piper | just another nail | on mismanagement | on false promises | on saving face | on sinkholes | playing catspaw | a moral hazard | making fake news | on crying poor | train wreck | fair play | faking it | on empty promises | on the perils of parking | on double-dipping | no news | on false pretences | on narcissism | none so blind | story book | a case for reform | on reform | on flights of fantasy | on liquid learning | the new normal | on trickery | paying the piper | on transparency | games they play | on avoidance | how good is this | time to stop digging | on consultation | on predatory behviour | it's never too late | on overreach | taking care of business | well done | kerching | simply pathetic | fraud alert | on scams | media games | ruling the roost | short circuit | on excuses | on mismanagement | great job | radio games | risky business | fair & balanced | alarum, alarum | go figure | on trust | just asking | when fools rush in | on dysfunction | people power | on tall tales | just an idea | about a town square near us | the theatre of the absurd | on consultation | the first law of holes | on accountability | a bridge too far | on nonsense | on sleight of hand | on caterwauling councils | great job | fool me once, shame on you | the sounds of silence | a ship of fools | on the getting of wisdom | clueless | on trivial pursuits | the value of a wall | a cautionary tale | a matter of trust | while Rome burns | on junk science | on a wing & a prayer | on false pretenses | absolute bullshit | the right to choose | a common purpose | on epic delusions | a tin ear | time to walk the talk | on snake oil | party time | theatre of the absurd | from the dark side | on getting SMART | from the scene of the crime | whither Numbugga | land games | just keeping-up appearances | look at me, look at me | the dangers of closed minds | on organised crime | a cautionary tale | on just desserts | ship of fools | on muddy waters | on total confusion | on public confidence | fakery | the myth of financial transparency | what's in a name | lies of convenience | a culture of secrecy | on virtue signalling | a common purpose | on hiding from the light | on comic relief | playing with the numbers | a flying circus | on charades | building mediocrity | flying blind | a question of accountability | flights of fantasy | on administrative ineptness | Happy New Year | same old, same old | on openness & transparency | none so blind | through a looking glass | real world simulated environments | turning ignorance to bliss | great news | on community | a blight on the landscape | in the valley of despair | on sleight of hand | theatre of the absurd | on the loss of trust | just the facts | on wheels within wheels | emergency landings | on commercial giants | on pork-barrelling | on high expectations | the smell of blood in the water | Ratepayer Groups Collaborate | the sky is falling | on ineptitude | the sounds of silence | on opinion polls | on contrariness | on more avoidance | on rent-seeking | on a wing & a prayer | the grants racket - welcome to the big time | on consultation | the grants racket - a world of deception | in search of service | on public trust | on oversight | on avoidance | on appearance over substance | poor Andrew | a question of leadership | same old, same old | Zingel Place Realty: Mayoral Election Special | so much for community | from the palace of dreams | in plain sight | new beginnings | the blind leading the blind | on false economy | on sod-turning | on mediocrity | on pedal power | Community Disaster Relief Fund | rules of convenience | like a well-oiled machine | on opportunity | well done council | shine the light | gimme, gimme, gimme | in the land of the blind | on the road to ruin | once more under a bus dear friends | dirty little secrets | walking the walk | the wages of greed | on a point of order | the games they play | on council secrets | Complaint to Information & Privacy Commission | Tathra Bushfires - Keelty Review | a stone in their shoe | truly a sad joke | Save Frogs Hollow | on poor behaviour | the public interest | saluting Orwell | great job | on the nose | on openness & transparency | on feeding the chooks | faking it | on hypocrisy | on "adequate" parking | on delusions of grandeur | on second-rate service | on like minds | same old, same old | supermarket city | on secrecy | on the "wages of spin" | on the artful dodge | on false promises | on the numbers | on foul odours | keeping-up appearances | on being nimble | some council | time out | same old, same old | fake news | on empty promises | on a 'burning platform' | like a drunken sailor | nothing to see here | on public officials | on tourist traps | playing deckchairs | on Grants | on messages | on free spirit | blowin' smoke | organised crimes | so much for Miss Marple | Code of Conduct Complaint - Cr Liz Seckold | the blind leading the blind | on the abuse of power | on loose cannons | the fix | on fakery | a gift horse | all hat, no paddock | the tourism con | on anonymous officials | development opportunities | on performance | on manipulation | a fair go | a law unto itself | yet another developer in paradise | a developer in paradise | on public opinion | taking care of business | a connected learning centre | on "complaints management" | Sydney or the Bush | on the nose | an avoidable disaster | once upon a party | real commitent | the fluoridation fix | on special deals | on the code of conduct | flights of fantasy | it's time | on "mature" behaviour | BVSRRA 2017 Annual General Meeting | on self-importance | the Minister with no clothes | on charades | not a good look | on the numbers | on accountability | on avoidance | a tainted process | so much for due diligence | Old Eden Tip Contamination Issue | whatever it takes | to fluoridate or not to fluoridate | crisis management | by the numbers | more dirty water | our most valuable asset | on deception | Bega TAFE update | the secret life of clocks | on games some councillors play | a public disgrace | from the sideline | taking care of business | half measures | on knuckle-dragging | house rules | the stress of it all | Bumbledom | know them by what they do | still fakin' it | on planning | just roads | on troubled waters | inviting betrayal | time's up | on accountability | sleight of hand | from "fake news" central | mixed messages | Bega TAFE | know them by what they do | on monuments to stupidity | dodgy numbers | on monumental incompetence | on integrity | false witness | the never ending circus | not "Our ABC" | so much for due diligence | on empty gestures | change, she's a coming | fake news | crash landing | avoiding accountability | great mysteries | if the cap fits | faking it | media bias | no confidence | NSW Health | The Hon Andrew Constance | the planning game | beware the 'troll' | Whose ABC? | the second coming | catspaw? | just another flimflam man | Vail Dr Chris Phoon | on rent-seeking | crumbs | the price of poor advice | while Rome burns | rank amateurs | Weasel Words | The Section 64 Circus | budgeting within OUR means | code of conduct process abise | where the rubber hits the road | health Hazzards | more smoke 'n mirrors | NSW Health | interesting times | theatre of the absurd | closed sessions | code of conduct complaints | bad faith | another fractured fairytale | nothing to see here | from the 'Palace of Dreams' | time to get real | Appearance vs Substance | conflicted | the politics of fluoride | wages of spin | the challenge of governance | Sydney or the bush | behind the eight ball | at the end of the line | the leadership thing | beware the fantasy man | taking care of business | more "fake" news | from the complaints department | fellow traveller | nothing to see here | The Hon Andrew Constance MP | quality water | mixed messages | poor planning | the lords of Zingel Place | in search of answers | fakin' it | work in progress | a burning platform | carry on cruising | nothing to see here | fantasyland | the plot thickens | commercial gain vs community benefit | fake news | just a little accountability | still not listening | a tangled web | risky business | out of sight, out of mind | empty gestures | a tin ear | rude awakenings | what planning | air turbulence warning | the new ugly | the value of submissions | on the grass | muddy waters | the challenges of engagement | who knows | on planning & development | community engagement | a rose by any other name | faking it | a meeting of minds | the real deal | appearance vs substance | an abuse of power | lip service | on public opinion | way to go | leading by example | message alerts | false promises | engagement with Council | a cone of silence | from fantasyland | we're saved | blowin' smoke | the wages of spin | lifting our game | playing patience | taking care of business | it would be nice to be asked | from the slow lane | building engagement | ready, fire, aim | the perils of planning | under the radar | looking for answers | the dark art of traffic management | Andrew who | shine the light | fluff | our right to know | the central planners' ball | flying school | the wrong voice | deja vu | causeway complications | Annual General Meetings | Special General Meetings | Contact Us | General Site Map
Copyright 2015. All rights reserved.
Back to content | Back to main menu